Yes. Not to say she wasn't thin during this time, but you can see the warp of the concrete behind her from when they pushed over the pixels to exaggerate her slender frame.. If she were that thin, it would show elsewhere in her body. I know, sometimes I can't believe I do this shit for a living -.- editing photos of beautiful people who don't need editing #graphicdesignprobs

Difficult, but i say yes. I'm not sure

She looks worryingly skinny

no this is right before artpop era were her ex label manager told her that she needed to loose a lot of weight for the ARTPOP campaign you can just see in gaga's eyes how unhappy she was back then