Because she was seen as a disney star.

it's probably because she didn't used to be like this- she was innocent in our childhood and people don't like change

Cause she's pathetic

Because hers seems different. Quite obvious that it is a publicity stunt. Video has no theme at all.

gaga did it for a photoshoot,miley and katy and rihanna did this for a music video so everybody will see the video and not the photoshoot

its also copying

I like Miley, she's just herself, even if she's bad. It's better that she's a naturally bad, not a superfake polite.

The difference is the rest didn't do it as a lash out over a broken heart. She can do whatever the f she wants but when the world can see why you're doing it and it's almost "forced" then it just becomes sad and sadder to watch!

mm

I criticize her because I really hate her tongue out of her mouth. Ive had enough!

maybe because she kept licking a hammer?

Because the world was used to Miley’s image as a celebrity for kids, so it’s kinda hard to get used to a new image, and some people also think that the kids who still watch Hannah Montana and look up Miley Cyrus might learn such stuff from her.

Because she has grown in a very short time...

This is one of the best posts to question the criticism Miley got after this video. I think she should be able to do this types of art too.

I'm so happy to see one fan base defend another good job monsters

I think it's because she is still fairly young. She is what... 20? The other artists shown are in their later 20s so it's seen as more "appropriate".

Because this video followed an outrageous performance on national televeision.

no, is cause the face and nude was so out of context, she is doing this just for call our attention and the others was just for artistic or stectic reasons. And is not just the nude is the sexy face so out of context, (you know the song is about pain, not sex) the licking... so, the nude is good but not all the time and not in every context with no reason for

No one is talking about Miley anymore...

Give Miley a break guys, she struggles so much with growing up in the public eye. She is trying to figure out the artist thing out and sometimes she trips and fall. lets take some time and think of what she's trying to tell us. She says she's scared and hurt and confused in this world.