I think the first photo is photoshopped by some hater but when not then it's still great . ;)

I love that outfit on the right, she looks hawt lol

Okay cool, but I honestly couldn't any care less than I do know about Gaga's body image, she doesn't need to be stick thin. Anybody else?

I think she looks really beautiful on the photoshopped picture :)

ppl are so fucked like 2 weeks ago she was 1 meter away from me and she looked skinney

i don't think it's been photoshopped. but it doesn't matter either way, we don't need to prove anything to haters, as long as she is healthy.

no matter she is fat or not she is just born this way!! she is always beautiful !!!!

In the pic on the right there is a face on her left knee-cap. :)

lets be real now true little monsters would love her no matter what.

THE SPRAY TAN IS FADING LOL !!!!

I don't care if she's gaining a little weight but the picture on the right was older than in the left

I think she looks amazing in the first one

I'm here because i love her music and voice... not her big sexy ass!!!

Who cares? Either one is a just limbs. This to me is no better than being a hater.

Not to sound rude but I think whoever Photoshopped the picture on the left did a poor job. It is obviously fake.

Both are flaw free anyways

who the fuck even cares? we shouldnt be saying "shes skinny this is fake" we should be saying "we dont care what she looks like"

fat or thin she is beautiful ♥

hey if that one was real hey, its more gaga to love!

In the photoshop one I don't even think she looks fat