OK. with or without make up to the people like. the title is not important. the important thing here is her in this photo. :)

She has makeup in all of these. the third, clearly. the fourth is obvious since her eyes don't always look at big, and the second, here eyebrows and eyelashes. first: eyes, brows, lips, hair...Always gorgeous.

Lol third picture is clearly not natural. sorry

but it's natural...

she's clearly wearing makeup in the third pic ..

Without makeup? Uhm, lol. I love Gaga, but hun. She's wearing makeup in ALL of these pics xD!